A few weeks ago as I was driving home, I noticed a group of baby geese attempting to cross the road I was travelling on. I braked, came to a complete stop and waited patiently as they crossed to the other side. Once I saw they were safe, I continued on my merry way home. Sadly, a Canadian woman named Emma Czornobaj did a similar thing on a Montreal highway four years ago and has now become a convicted murderer because of it.
For those who haven’t read this in the news yet, Czornobaj was driving on this Montreal highway in 2010 when she saw a family of ducklings in the middle of it. Concerned for their safety, like I was the other day for those baby geese, she suddenly stopped in the left lane hoping to help them. Meanwhile, Andre Roy, 50, was travelling closely behind on his Harley Davidson with his 16-year old daughter Jessie, when he suddenly slammed into Czornobaj’s stopped car. Andre died on the scene, while his daughter Jessie later did in a hospital nearby. Police reports state that Andre was speeding somewhere between 70 and 80 miles per hour in an area where the limit was only 60. But a jury unanimously convicted Czornobaj last week as the sole responsibility of this 2010 tragedy with two counts of criminal negligence causing death and two counts of dangerous driving causing death. The first carries a maximum life sentence, while the second comes with a potential of up to 14 more years in jail.
When I first saw this ruling in the news, I thought about my own many near misses of wildlife crossing roads I’ve been on over the years. In every case, I’ve always slowed down or come to a complete stop when I’ve seen any of it. Czornobaj was no different as she had love in her heart for some baby ducks she observed on the highway that day. Yet, a motorcyclist who was excessively speeding was not held with any responsibility in this terrible tragedy.
If there were anyone you’d think would blame Czornobaj the most for this accident, it would have been Andre Roy’s wife. She actually witnessed the whole thing as she too was driving on the highway that day, except more slowly from behind her husband’s motorcycle. But, she has openly stated she finds no fault in Czornobaj at all. The courts have directed otherwise though and imposed a ruling that I struggle greatly with to spiritually understand.
Day in and day out in this world, there are murderers, rapists, and violent offenders who escape conviction, yet a woman with no criminal intent in her heart is facing years to a potential lifetime in jail, all for the fact of her trying to help some wildlife survive. All of this has made me wonder even more about the legal systems of this world, and especially with where the hearts of those jurors were when they came up with the severity of Czornobaj’s ruling. While I do clearly see how there was some driver’s negligence on Czornobaj’s part for this accident, I can’t fathom her verdict nor can I grasp why an excessively speeding motorcyclist wasn’t held at fault for any part of it.
I do my best today to not speed when I drive, and I definitely believe if I was following too closely behind someone who braked for some wildlife, that it would be my fault if I ended up hitting them. Truthfully, I’m grateful for anyone today that brakes for God’s creatures trying to cross the road because I believe that all life matters. I always find it so sad when I see drivers and motorcyclists do the exact opposite when they run them over.
Sometimes things like this never make any sense to me on a spiritual level as to the how and why they play themselves out as they do. It is a tragedy that two deaths occurred because of Czornobaj’s attempt to help some baby ducks, but does someone like her who carries love in her heart for life itself deserve to go away for years, to possible life in jail because of it? I guess the only thing I can do is pray for God’s will in this matter and to do continue doing exactly as I’ve always done when I see any wildlife in the middle of the road, I’ll stop and try to protect it…
Peace, love, light, and joy,
Andrew Arthur Dawson
spiritually what is more important a duck or a human? The cycle of life we don’t see every day living in the city is that animals are part of the cycle of life where one kills another to live and we as humans kill another animal to live. I believe that one has to think of their actions and how they will effect human life first as we are the one with a soul. There are many factors in this case and she is not 100% at fault for the death of the 2 people but at the same time she made a decision to protect animals first before herself or other humans.
i think that the womens behavior was reckless and foolish, i would have done the same thing
You dont know if the rider would have killed himself and his daughter swerving to avoid those ducks
Life isnt fair and unfortunately, sometimes neither is justice. Animals dont have souls?